Raiders,
daily.

Lists

Lists

The 5 best tight ends, with receiving and blocking weighted equally

Half the job is catching the ball. The other half never shows up in a box score.

By ·

This is a let's-have-an-argument list. Five tight ends, ranked with receiving and blocking counted equally. Receiving is easy to measure. Blocking isn't, because there's no statistic for it, so it's judged on the record: All-Pro and Hall of Fame citations, what coaches and teammates said, grading where it exists, and the offenses these players blocked for. Any era counts, and careers run through the end of the 2025 season. That rule costs Tony Gonzalez, the most productive receiver the position has had, a place, because the evidence on his blocking is thin. If you think blocking deserves less weight, or a name here doesn't belong, say so.

  1. 1

    Rob Gronkowski

    Patriots and Buccaneers, 2010-21: 621 catches, 9,286 yards, 92 TD; four first-team All-Pros, four Super Bowl titles

    The only tight end with elite evidence on both halves of the job. Rob Gronkowski caught 621 passes for 9,286 yards and 92 touchdowns, including a tight end record 17 in 2011, made first-team All-Pro four times and won four Super Bowls. On the other half, Bill Belichick called him one of the best blockers and put him in the same class as Mark Bavaro, and the NFL's 100th-anniversary team described his blocking as a throwback to when the tight end was virtually an extra lineman. He's on that all-time team and the 2010s all-decade team, and he's the only player on this list with more than one Super Bowl ring. The counterargument is totals: 621 catches is less than half of Tony Gonzalez's 1,325. On this list, the blocking makes up the difference and then some.

    Sources: Wikipedia: Rob Gronkowski · StatMuse · Patriots.com · NBC Sports: Belichick on Gronkowski · NFL.com: all-time team · NFL.com: 2010s all-decade team.

  2. 2

    John Mackey

    Colts and Chargers, 1963-72: 331 catches, 5,236 yards, 38 TD; three first-team All-Pros, Hall of Fame 1992

    The prototype. The Hall of Fame describes John Mackey as a tight end with breakaway speed, hard to tackle and a strong blocker, and the Colts call him a punishing blocker with speed. That's both halves in two sentences from the people who watched him. He caught 331 passes for 5,236 yards and 38 touchdowns, averaging 15.8 yards a catch, was first-team All-Pro three straight years from 1966 to 1968, and caught a 75-yard touchdown in Super Bowl V, a Super Bowl record at the time, in a game Baltimore won. He's on the NFL's 50th- and 100th-anniversary teams. The counterargument is the totals, which look modest next to modern tight ends. The position those modern tight ends play is the one he defined.

    Sources: Pro Football Hall of Fame · Colts.com · Wikipedia: John Mackey · NFL.com: all-time team.

  3. 3

    Mike Ditka

    Bears, Eagles and Cowboys, 1961-72: 427 catches, 5,812 yards, 43 TD; first tight end in the Hall of Fame

    Mike Ditka was the first tight end in the Hall of Fame, and he got there on both halves. As a Bears rookie in 1961 he caught 56 passes for 1,076 yards and 12 touchdowns, the first rookie tight end to reach 1,000 yards, and he made the Pro Bowl in each of his first five seasons. The Hall calls him a superior blocker, and the NFL's 100th-anniversary team notes the pride he took in blocking for Gale Sayers. He finished with 427 catches for 5,812 yards and 43 touchdowns and scored the final touchdown of Dallas's 24-3 win in Super Bowl VI. He's also the only person on this list who won a Super Bowl as a head coach, with the 1985 Bears. The counterargument is that he's ranked below Mackey despite more catches and more yards. Mackey's average was higher, 15.8 to 13.6.

    Sources: Pro Football Hall of Fame · Wikipedia: Mike Ditka · Sports Illustrated · NFL.com: all-time team · Britannica.

  4. 4

    Dave Casper

    Raiders, Oilers and Vikings, 1974-84: 378 catches, 5,216 yards, 52 TD; four straight first-team All-Pros, Hall of Fame 2002

    Dave Casper said it himself: "I'm only a fair pass receiver. I'm a better blocker." John Madden, his coach, called him possibly the best blocking tight end he'd had. The receiving record says Casper undersold himself. He caught 378 passes for 5,216 yards and 52 touchdowns and was first-team All-Pro four straight years, 1976 to 1979. He won Super Bowl XI, made the 1970s all-decade first team and went into the Hall of Fame in 2002. The counterargument is Tony Gonzalez, whose receiving numbers dwarf Casper's. That's the trade this list makes. Casper's blocking has a Super Bowl-winning coach's word behind it. Gonzalez's doesn't.

    Sources: Pro Football Hall of Fame: The Ghost · Pro Football Hall of Fame · Raiders.com · Wikipedia: Dave Casper.

  5. 5

    George Kittle

    49ers, 2017-present: 595 catches, 8,008 yards, 52 TD through 2025; two first-team All-Pros, seven Pro Bowls

    The best case for a current player. George Kittle has caught 595 passes for 8,008 yards and 52 touchdowns through the 2025 season, with four 1,000-yard seasons, two first-team All-Pro selections and seven Pro Bowls. On the other half, Pro Football Focus rated his career run blocking the best at the position over a decade, and Kyle Shanahan called him the best blocking tight end who's also a pass-game player. The counterargument is that his career isn't finished and he hasn't won a Super Bowl. Travis Kelce has three titles and more than 13,000 receiving yards, but the evidence on Kelce's blocking is thin, and on this list that matters as much as the catches.

    Sources: StatMuse · Pro Football Reference · Wikipedia: George Kittle · PFF · 49ers.com · StatMuse: Kelce.

More lists

Every list →

Comments