Week 10 picks · Mea culpa
Mahomes throws five touchdowns on a sore elbow as Falcons +3.5 loses
Mea culpa
We wrote this one without knowing who would play quarterback, and we said out loud that if Mahomes practiced fully and looked right, the honest number was Kansas City. He practiced, he looked right, and he went 22 of 35 for 348 yards and five touchdowns on a sprained elbow. Emmett Johnson added 101 rushing yards and two scores. Drake London's 109 receiving yards were decoration. Chiefs 35, Falcons 13, a miss by 18.5, and the hedge was the mistake.
loss Chiefs 35, Falcons 13
The pick: Falcons +3.5 vs Chiefs
The case before kickoff
Patrick Mahomes hurt his elbow in Week 9, came back in that game and is being called day to day, so this pick is written without knowing who plays quarterback. We make it Chiefs -2.5; the market says -3.5. With a healthy Mahomes our number is closer to a touchdown and we'd be laying it; with Justin Fields we'd want Atlanta plus a lot more than this. Blending the two, and discounting a Mahomes who throws with a sore elbow, gets us to the Falcons side by a point, and we'd rather have the dog than lay 3.5 into that uncertainty. On the field, Atlanta just traded Jessie Bates to Jacksonville, which is a bad week to be short a safety against Travis Kelce at 0.54 EPA per target, and Kansas City's secondary is the reason we don't love Atlanta more: they allow minus 0.01 EPA per target to wide receivers, fifth best in the league, and that's Drake London's problem all afternoon. Atlanta's run path is the one thing the matchup likes, with Bijan Robinson at 5.2 yards a carry against a Kansas City front allowing minus 0.11 EPA a rush, so somebody has to win that. Say it plainly: this is a medium-conviction dog whose value depends on a Friday designation, and if Mahomes practices fully and looks right, the honest number is on Kansas City.
Reporting: NBC Sports Pro Football Talk: Mahomes throws five TDs · ESPN: Mahomes stars for Chiefs · Pro Football Reference box scores