By Taurean Matador · . Baseline week; movement starts the next week. Updated Tuesday, September 22: Georgia moved up to fifth, and the Heisman watch is new.
Our first FBS Top 25 won't look like the AP poll. It ranks what teams have done on the field this season, not what they were expected to do in August.
Ole Miss has the best résumé in the country, with wins over Louisville and LSU. It sits second because of our one standing exception: the defending champion keeps No. 1 until somebody takes it, and Indiana hasn't allowed a point in two weeks. Georgia is fifth on an editorial call rather than the formula: a four-touchdown SEC road win, with Oklahoma coming to Athens on Saturday to test it. LSU is sixth with a loss, because a one-possession defeat at the No. 2 team plus a 41-point win over Clemson is the best one-loss case in the country. Mississippi State and Miami each have two road wins over power-conference teams, and it shows.
This weekend sorts out a lot: Texas at Tennessee, Ole Miss at Florida, Iowa at Michigan, Oregon at USC, Missouri at Mississippi State and Oklahoma State at West Virginia.
Method
Results only. Preseason polls, recruiting rankings, coaching hires and offseason talk don't count. The inputs are who a team beat, where the game was played, and by how much.
Who you beat matters most: a win over a good team outweighs any blowout of a bad one, and opponent quality is judged by how those opponents have played this season. A road win counts for more than a neutral-site win, and a neutral-site win for more than a home win. A close road loss to a top team can rank above an unbeaten record against weak opponents. Margin breaks ties between similar résumés; it won't lift a team past one with better wins.
One exception: the defending national champion holds No. 1 until it loses. Every Monday the Top 25 is rebuilt from scratch, not shuffled from last week's list. Three games is a thin résumé, so expect more movement in September than in November. When a placement is an editorial call that departs from this method, the team's note says so.
Also considered: Vanderbilt, Houston, SMU, Washington, Texas A&M.
Players of the week
Week 3's best single-game performances in the country, picked on the same terms as this Top 25. Why each one won →
OffenseMichael Hawkins Jr.QB · West Virginia10 of 17, 190 yards, 2 TD, 0 INT; 18 rushes, 123 yards, 3 TD
DefenseKaleb BeasleyDB · No. 23 Louisville10 tackles, 2 INT (caught at the Louisville 18 and 15)
Special teamsJaren HamiltonKR · Arizona State100-yard kickoff return for a touchdown to open the second half
Heisman watch
Five players, ranked on the same terms as our NFL MVP watch: production adjusted for efficiency and mistakes, the defenses faced, how much of the offense runs through them and how much help they have. College adds one more: level of competition. Numbers against FCS teams count for little, and a win over a weak FBS team counts for less than one over a good team. Team record counts, but only a little. Every position is eligible; anyone who isn't a quarterback has to be exceptional. Three games is a thin sample.
The strongest case because of who he's done it against. Ole Miss hasn't played an FCS team, and its two best wins came over Louisville and LSU, whose only losses are to Ole Miss. Chambliss threw for 336 yards against Louisville and 363 against LSU, and he accounts for 74 percent of the Rebels' yards, a bigger share than anyone else on this list. The case against: 8.4 yards per attempt is the lowest of the five, and both interceptions came in those two big games.
Twelve touchdowns accounted for, second in the country behind Jayden Maiava, who has played one more game. Two of Taylor's three games were road trips to power-conference teams: 227 passing yards, three touchdowns and 86 rushing yards at Minnesota, then four touchdown passes at South Carolina. He has one interception, averages 10.1 yards per attempt and accounts for two-thirds of the Bulldogs' offensive touchdowns. What keeps him second is the opposition: Minnesota and South Carolina aren't Louisville and LSU.
3
Darian Mensah
QB · Miami (3-0)
71 of 79, 873 yards, 11 TD, 0 INT
The most accurate passer in the country at 89.9 percent, with 11 touchdowns and no interceptions. He opened with 400 yards and five touchdowns at Stanford and completed his first 24 passes at Wake Forest, an ACC record. Both were road wins. The discounts: three of those touchdowns came against Florida A&M, an FCS team, and neither Stanford nor Wake Forest is good. He also has more help than the two above him, since Malachi Toney's 444 receiving yards rank second in FBS.
4
Jeremiah Smith
WR · Ohio State (2-1)
21 catches, 400 yards, 3 TD
Fourth on an editorial call, and we'll say so plainly: this list needs its best non-quarterback case, and Smith is it. His 400 receiving yards rank fourth in FBS and make up 38 percent of Ohio State's passing yards. His best game came against the best opponent, eight catches for 164 yards and a touchdown at Texas, our No. 3 team. He opened with 151 yards and two touchdowns against Ball State. The case against: Miami's Malachi Toney has more yards, and Ohio State lost in Austin.
The clearest example of a player who is most of his team's offense. Hawkins has run for 322 yards, the most of any FBS quarterback, and accounts for 11 of West Virginia's 16 offensive touchdowns, the biggest share on this list. At Virginia he ran for 123 yards and three touchdowns and threw for two more. The case against a higher spot: four of his touchdowns came against UT Martin, an FCS team, and he has lost a fumble.
Also considered: Jayden Maiava, USC (FBS-high 1,173 passing yards and 12 TD passes, against San Jose State, Fresno State, Louisiana and Rutgers); Jadan Baugh, Florida RB (458 rushing yards and 8 TD, including 162 and 3 TD at Auburn); Keelon Russell, Alabama (6 total TD in wins at Kentucky and over Florida State); Josh Hoover, Indiana (12.7 yards per attempt, but on 51 attempts, with 4 of his 10 TD against Howard).
1
Indiana
3-0New
beat Western Kentucky 38-0 at home
W 52-16 N. Texas
W 55-0 Howard
W 38-0 W. Kentucky
Defending champions, and No. 1 under the one exception to the method. It was 7-0 deep into the second quarter after a goal-line stand on Western Kentucky's first-and-goal, then Indiana pulled away. Josh Hoover went 18 of 24 for 273 yards and Turbo Richard ran for 149. The defense allowed 186 yards and posted a second straight shutout. It's the 19th straight win. Nobody on the schedule has tested them yet; Northwestern comes to Bloomington on Friday night.
2
Ole Miss
3-0New
beat LSU 32-24 at home
W 41-38 Louisville (N)
W 41-9 Charlotte
W 32-24 LSU
The best résumé in the country: two ranked wins, one at a neutral site and one at home. Against Lane Kiffin's LSU, Ole Miss led 24-7 at halftime, lost the whole lead in the third quarter, then retook it on a Trinidad Chambliss touchdown run and a two-point conversion. Chambliss finished 33 of 48 for 363 yards. LSU drove to first-and-goal late, and Jaylon Braxton ended it by catching a tipped fourth-down pass. Next: at Florida.
3
Texas
3-0New
beat UTSA 30-6 at home
W 59-7 Texas St.
W 24-23 Ohio State
W 30-6 UTSA
A routine 24-point win the week after the biggest result of the season. The case for Texas is still the 24-23 win over Ohio State, when the Longhorns came back from 20 points down in the fourth quarter. UTSA scored six points. Saturday brings the first road game of the year, at Tennessee.
4
Alabama
3-0New
beat Florida State 50-36 at home
W 48-10 E. Carolina
W 45-17 at Kentucky
W 50-36 Florida St.
Weather pushed kickoff back nearly two hours and stopped play again before halftime, and Florida State kept it closer than the Tide wanted. Keelon Russell was 23 of 30 for 320 yards and three touchdowns and added a 57-yard touchdown run. The 36 points allowed is a warning. The 45-17 win at Kentucky looks better every week, since Kentucky just won at Texas A&M.
5
Georgia
3-0New
won 45-17 at Arkansas
W 63-3 Tennessee St.
W 70-20 W. Kentucky
W 45-17 at Arkansas
Fifth on an editorial call rather than the formula, and we'll say so plainly. By the method, the résumé is thin: Arkansas is 1-2, with its only win over an FCS team, and the other two wins came against Tennessee State and Western Kentucky. But the Arkansas game was a four-touchdown SEC road win. Georgia ran for 254 yards and four touchdowns and led 38-3 before easing off, and Gunner Stockton ran for 97 yards, 62 of them on one play. Oklahoma visits Athens on Saturday, and that game decides whether fifth holds.
6
LSU
2-1New
lost 32-24 at Ole Miss
W 51-10 Clemson
W 45-14 La. Tech
L 24-32 at Ole Miss
Sixth with a loss, and it's earned. LSU trailed 24-7 at halftime in the loudest road building it will see all year, tied the game in the fourth quarter, and drove to first-and-goal in the final two minutes before a tipped pass was intercepted. Add a 51-10 opening win over Clemson and nobody else in the country with a loss has a better case.
7
Louisville
2-1New
beat SMU 41-31 at home
L 38-41 Ole Miss (N)
W 59-13 Villanova
W 41-31 SMU
A game with seven lead changes. SMU went ahead 31-28 before Keyjaun Brown answered with a 53-yard touchdown run. A late SMU touchdown was overturned on review and ruled a fumble, and Kaleb Beasley intercepted Kevin Jennings on the final possession. The only loss is by three to our No. 2, on a field goal as time expired.
8
Ohio State
2-1New
beat Kent State 59-3 at home
W 56-3 Ball State
L 23-24 at Texas
W 59-3 Kent State
A 56-point win over Kent State, the second blowout of a MAC team this month. The résumé is two blowouts of MAC teams and a one-point road loss, after holding a 20-point fourth-quarter lead, to our No. 3. By results, that's the best one-loss profile among teams whose loss wasn't to Ole Miss. Illinois comes to Columbus next.
9
Notre Dame
3-0New
beat Michigan State 27-10 at home
W 41-13 Wisconsin
W 52-0 Rice
W 27-10 Mich. State
Workmanlike rather than dominant. CJ Carr went 18 of 24 for 234 yards and Nolan James Jr. ran for 121. The defense held Michigan State to 167 total yards and 40 in the second half. Two home wins over Big Ten teams by 28 and 17 is a solid start. What's missing is a road game, and the first one is Saturday at Purdue.
10
Miami
3-0New
won 33-20 at Wake Forest
W 45-6 at Stanford
W 77-7 Florida A&M
W 33-20 at Wake Forest
Two road wins over power-conference teams, including a cross-country trip to Stanford in Week 1. On Friday night at Wake Forest, Darian Mensah completed his first 24 passes, an ACC record. Neither road opponent is good, but winning away from home by a combined 52 points is the kind of result this method rewards.
11
Utah
3-0New
beat Utah State 33-0 at home
W 66-14 Idaho
W 43-10 Arkansas
W 33-0 Utah State
The most overlooked unbeaten team in the country. Utah beat Arkansas by 33; Georgia beat the same Arkansas team by 28. Georgia did it on the road, which is why the Bulldogs rank higher. Saturday's shutout of Utah State was the Utes' second game this season holding an opponent to 10 points or fewer. First road test: at Iowa State.
12
Mississippi State
3-0New
won 41-34 at South Carolina
W 62-13 La.-Monroe
W 38-13 at Minnesota
W 41-34 at S. Carolina
Two road wins over power-conference opponents, one in the Big Ten and one in the SEC. Nobody ranked below them can say that. Kamario Taylor threw four touchdown passes in Columbia to hold off South Carolina. The defense allowed 34, which will get tested when Missouri comes to Starkville on Saturday night.
13
Michigan
3-0New
beat UTEP 52-17 at home
W 13-12 W. Michigan
W 17-10 Oklahoma
W 52-17 UTEP
The final looks comfortable. It wasn't early: two turnovers let UTEP pull within 17-14 before Michigan outscored the Miners 35-3 the rest of the way. The 17-10 win over Oklahoma is a real result. The one-point escape against Western Michigan in Week 1 is why they sit here and not in the top 10. Iowa visits Ann Arbor on Saturday.
14
Kentucky
2-1New
won 31-21 at Texas A&M
W 45-13 Youngstown St.
L 17-45 Alabama
W 31-21 at Texas A&M
The best road win of the weekend. Kentucky led the ninth-ranked Aggies 28-7 entering the fourth quarter at Kyle Field. Kenny Minchey went 14 of 18 for 252 yards and two touchdowns. Jordan Castell had 13 tackles and an interception. It was Kentucky's first win over A&M since 1952. What holds them at 14 is a 28-point home loss to Alabama.
15
Tennessee
3-0New
beat Kennesaw State 42-9 at home
W 56-9 Furman
W 45-24 at Georgia Tech
W 42-9 Kennesaw St.
One road win over a power-conference team, 45-24 at Georgia Tech. The other two wins came against Furman and Kennesaw State. Saturday is the first real measuring stick: Texas at Neyland Stadium at noon.
16
Texas Tech
3-0New
beat Houston 28-26 at home
W 33-10 Abilene Chr.
W 35-24 at Oregon St.
W 28-26 Houston
A ranked win, but barely. Houston was No. 22 at the time and lost by two in Lubbock on Friday night. The 11-point road win at Oregon State is fine, not memorable. Texas Tech is unbeaten and unconvincing, and its next two games (Sam Houston, then at Colorado) won't tell us much more.
17
West Virginia
3-0New
won 38-27 at Virginia
W 31-24 Coastal Car.
W 52-7 UT Martin
W 38-27 at Virginia
Michael Hawkins Jr. accounted for five touchdowns, three rushing and two passing, as West Virginia won in Charlottesville against a ranked team. He's the first Mountaineers quarterback to do that since Pat White in 2008. The Week 1 seven-point win over Coastal Carolina keeps the ceiling in check. Oklahoma State visits Morgantown on Saturday.
18
Penn State
3-0New
beat Buffalo 55-13 at home
W 45-0 Marshall
W 27-9 at Temple
W 55-13 Buffalo
Outscored three opponents 127-22, and the Buffalo game only added to it. Rocco Becht has been efficient and the defense has given up almost nothing. The problem is the schedule: none of those three teams is from a power conference. Under this method, teams with road wins over power-conference opponents rank ahead. Wisconsin visits on Saturday.
19
Florida
3-0New
won 44-39 at Auburn
W 66-21 FAU
W 52-3 Campbell
W 44-39 at Auburn
Won a shootout on the road in its SEC opener, the first game of the Jon Sumrall era against a real opponent. A road SEC win is a road SEC win. Allowing 39 points to Auburn is the concern, especially with Ole Miss coming to Gainesville on Saturday.
20
BYU
3-0New
won 41-23 at Colorado State
W 63-7 Utah Tech
W 28-17 Arizona
W 41-23 at Colorado St.
Handled a Mountain West road trip without trouble. The best win is 28-17 over Arizona at home in Week 2. BYU keeps winning comfortably without beating anyone who moves the needle. The schedule changes in October, with road games at TCU and a visit from Notre Dame.
21
Missouri
3-0New
beat Troy 27-17 at home
W 54-14 Ark.-Pine Bluff
W 38-21 at Kansas
W 27-17 Troy
The 17-point win at Kansas is the result that puts Missouri in. Saturday's 10-point home win over Troy was flat. Two SEC road games in the next five weeks, starting at Mississippi State on Saturday night, will show which version is real.
22
Oklahoma State
2-1New
beat Murray State 59-0 at home
L 10-24 at Tulsa
W 39-31 Oregon
W 59-0 Murray St.
The strangest résumé in the rankings: a 14-point loss at Tulsa, then a win over sixth-ranked Oregon. Saturday's shutout of an FCS team adds nothing. The Oregon win keeps them in; the Tulsa loss keeps them low. They play at West Virginia on Saturday.
23
USC
4-0New
won 42-35 at Rutgers
W 42-26 San Jose St.
W 39-0 Fresno St.
W 49-30 La.-Lafayette
W 42-35 at Rutgers
Four wins, none of them convincing against the level of opponent. USC led a Rutgers team that was 0-2 by one possession entering the fourth quarter and needed all of it. The Trojans have allowed 91 points to four teams without a ranked opponent among them. Oregon comes to the Coliseum on Saturday.
24
Oregon
2-1New
beat Portland State 84-0 at home
W 34-27 Boise State
L 31-39 at Oklahoma St.
W 84-0 Portland St.
An 84-0 win over an FCS team on Friday night tells us nothing. The résumé is a seven-point home win over Boise State and an eight-point road loss to Oklahoma State, which is why Oregon ranks behind the team that beat it. The trip to USC on Saturday decides which of these two stays in.
25
Iowa
3-0New
beat Northern Iowa 55-0 at home
W 40-0 N. Illinois
W 16-13 Iowa State
W 55-0 N. Iowa
Allowed 13 points in three games, all of them in the three-point win over Iowa State. That rivalry win is the whole résumé, and it came at home. The defense is legitimate. Saturday at Michigan is the first chance to prove the rest.
Next edition: Monday, September 28, after Week 4.
Comments
Get Raiders Daily in your inbox
The day in Raiders news every morning, plus picks, rankings and fantasy calls. Free.
Comments