College football · Week 5
College picks: Week 5, 2026
Every game with a Top 25 team, against the spread. Locked at kickoff, graded after the final whistle.
This week 9-6
Season 74-74-1
Week 5 sits six ranked teams on the shelf. Texas, Ole Miss, Utah, Oregon, Oklahoma State and UCLA are all idle, which leaves fifteen priced games and three that pair ranked against ranked: Alabama at Mississippi State, Ohio State at Iowa, Florida at Missouri. All three have the road team laying the points and all three sit inside two touchdowns. The heavy end of the board is Indiana and Georgia, both at 24.5, with Notre Dame 21.5 and SMU 21 behind them. Last week leaned on underdogs and went 7-11, so this card splits near even: seven favorites, eight dogs, each taken on its own arithmetic. Where a big number gets laid it is because the underdog cannot score. Where points get taken it is because the favorite has a bigger game the following week. LSU hosts McNeese with no book posting a side, so that one stays off the card.
Saturday, October 3
-
7 Alabama at 16 Mississippi St
Mississippi St +6 Mea culpa Alabama 56, Mississippi St 23
The line opened Alabama -3 and sits at -6, a full field goal of movement toward a team playing an 11am road game with two starting offensive linemen in question. Jayvin James is very much questionable at right tackle and Will Sanders is working back from an upper body injury. Alabama hosts Georgia next Saturday. Mississippi State has a bye after this and nothing else on the calendar. Rain sits at 73 percent in Starkville.
Mississippi State's unbeaten season comes apart in Starkville
Alabama put up 56 and never gave the number a second thought. Keelon Russell threw for 285 and three scores and added one on the ground, and Mississippi State's unbeaten run got dismantled in front of its own crowd. There was no late cover window here. This one was decided by the middle of the third quarter.
Taking the home dog with a field goal and change was a bet that Davis Wade would keep it close. It did not. The pick asked a defense that had not yet seen a real offense to hold one down, and Alabama hung 56 on it. That is not a bad beat. That is a bad read.
-
UCF at 20 Houston
UCF +10.5 Cashed UCF 17, Houston 27
SP+ separates these two by 3.4 points and the market by better than ten. Houston is 118th in adjusted EPA per play on defense, and UCF runs the slowest offense on the board at 57.5 snaps a game, which is how a dog shortens a game it should lose. Keyone Jenkins has started twice since Alonza Barnett went down with a hamstring and went 19 of 20 in an outright win over TCU. Storms are 74 percent for a noon kick.
Houston rallies past UCF and stops a half point short
Houston came out of the half a different team. Conner Weigman put up 239 through the air and ran in three touchdowns after the break to flip the game and take it 27 to 17. The Cougars got the win they came for and stopped exactly half a point short of the one that mattered on this ticket.
Ten and a half was the right side of a number the market set on reputation. UCF lost by ten. Cashed, and nobody is pretending the fourth quarter was comfortable.
-
Boston College at 21 SMU
Boston College +20.5 Cashed Boston College 16, SMU 25
SP+ has SMU by 17.6 on a neutral field, roughly 20 with the home field, against a posted number that has not moved a tick since it opened. SMU is on a six day week after beating Missouri State by ten at home. Boston College scores 19.8 a game and is not winning this, but its defense has six interceptions, fifth in the country, and that is the currency a three touchdown dog trades in.
Rain in Dallas, and three touchdowns was always too many
Wet night at Gerald J. Ford Stadium and the scoreboard behaved accordingly. Kevin Jennings threw two touchdowns and ran in a third, SMU took it 25 to 16, and the number was never in real danger. Boston College did not have to win anything. It had to stay inside three touchdowns, and it stayed inside two.
Twenty and a half against a Boston College team that plays slow and hits people, in weather that shortens the game, was the easiest call on the card. Cashed.
-
3 Notre Dame at North Carolina
Notre Dame -21.5 Mea culpa Notre Dame 37, North Carolina 26
Notre Dame allows 8.3 points and 199 yards a game, first in the country, and North Carolina is 102nd in scoring at 23.3. Belichick named Billy Edwards the starter but laid out a rotation with Miles O'Neill, which is not what a settled offense looks like. SP+ makes this about 22.6 once the home field is counted, so 21.5 is a shade under the honest number. Noon heat in Chapel Hill is the only real argument for a backdoor.
Notre Dame wins its 15th straight, the rain wins the cover
Notre Dame got the win and never got the blowout. Pouring rain in Chapel Hill took the passing game off the table for long stretches, CJ Carr had to work in a narrow margin, and North Carolina stayed close enough to keep the final at 37 to 26.
Laying three touchdowns on the road is a bet that the favorite can score whenever it decides to. Weather is the one thing that makes that impossible, and the forecast was not a secret Saturday morning. The pick looked at the talent gap and ignored the sky. Eleven points of win, ten and a half points of loss.
-
Vanderbilt at 2 Georgia
Vanderbilt +24.5 Cashed Vanderbilt 14, Georgia 38
The total fell from 57.5 to 50.5 with no injury to explain it, which is the market pricing a controlled Georgia win rather than a rout. Georgia goes to Alabama next Saturday, and Jared Curtis walks into Sanford Stadium having flipped his commitment out of it. Vanderbilt holds the ball 31:33 a game and covered both of its competitive games. Fewer possessions is how 24.5 stays out of reach.
Georgia scores in every quarter and misses by half a point
Georgia did everything a favorite is supposed to do. Gunner Stockton went 25 of 32 for 295 and three touchdowns, the defense shut Vanderbilt out after halftime, and Sanford Stadium got the 38 to 14 it paid for.
Then the arithmetic showed up. Twenty four and a half was the number. Vanderbilt lost by twenty four. Not one person in that building was thinking about the spread, and the spread did not care. Cashed on the hook.
-
8 Florida at 25 Missouri
Missouri +4.5 Cashed Florida 17, Missouri 45
Missouri lost this same number last week, but that was on the road in Starkville against a 4-0 team. This is Faurot Field off a first loss, and Missouri carries the best havoc rate in this group near 22 percent against a Florida line that has to protect 900 miles from home. Florida scores 54 a game and allows 29.3, 81st, so Missouri needs possessions more than stops. SP+ makes the honest number about 2.3.
Missouri was never a home dog, whatever the board said
Florida came to Columbia ranked eighth and left having surrendered 45. Austin Simmons went 23 of 30 for 340, Jamal Roberts ran for 211 and three scores, and Missouri snapped a nine game losing streak against ranked teams by roughly four touchdowns more than it needed.
The board had Missouri taking four and a half at home. That was the entire pick. Collect the points, pocket the outright, and stop caring about the line somewhere in the second quarter. Cashed.
-
Auburn at 17 Tennessee
Auburn +7 Mea culpa Auburn 14, Tennessee 24
Tennessee gave up ten sacks to Texas and Faizon Brandon took two hits worth noting, after which Heupel declined every injury question on Monday and pointed at Wednesday. Auburn snaps it every 20.8 seconds, fastest in the country, and its defense has 29 tackles for loss. This is Auburn's first true road game of the year, which is the risk, but Alex Golesh spent two seasons in this building as coordinator and has a bye next week.
Auburn gets seven points, Tennessee gets DeSean Bishop
DeSean Bishop ran for a career high 220 yards and three touchdowns and that was the game. Tennessee did not have to be clever in front of 101,915. It had to hand the ball off, and Auburn could not get off the field. Final 24 to 14, never inside the three points this needed.
Seven with Auburn was a bet on a close, ugly night in Knoxville. The ugly arrived. The close did not, because a defense that cannot stop one running back does not get to decide how close a game stays.
-
5 Ohio State at 14 Iowa
Iowa +13.5 Mea culpa Ohio State 31, Iowa 14
SP+ separates these two by 14.0 before Kinnick is counted, which makes the posted number one that ignores home field entirely. Iowa allows 8.0 points a game, first in the country, and has thrown one interception all season. The total of 45.5 is the second lowest on the board, and a two touchdown cover inside a 45 point game asks Ohio State for something like 31-14. Clear and 65 degrees, no weather help either way.
Kinnick stayed loud and Julian Sayin threw over the top of it
Iowa got the game it wanted for about a quarter. Then Julian Sayin threw for 324 and three touchdowns, two of them to Jeremiah Smith, and Ohio State walked out of Kinnick with a 31 to 14 win that stopped being interesting after halftime.
Thirteen and a half was a bet on the stadium, the field position grind and a low total, which is the standard way to get Iowa money. The flaw is plain now. That formula still requires Iowa to score, and 14 points does not cover anything against a quarterback and a receiver this good. The pick needed the Iowa offense to be functional. It was not.
-
24 Kentucky at South Carolina
Kentucky +2.5 Cashed Kentucky 35, South Carolina 34
South Carolina opened -7 and sits at -2.5, and the reason is on the availability sheet. Dylan Stewart, their best defender, is suspended indefinitely and will not play. That defense already gave up nine passing touchdowns in two weeks on a 73.6 percent completion rate, and now it has no edge rush. Kenny Minchey is completing 68.3 percent for a Kentucky team that won at Texas A&M. SP+ splits these two by half a point.
Kentucky trails 17 to nothing and wins it on a two point play
Kentucky was down 17 to 0 in the second quarter and won the thing in overtime. Adam Zouagui hit from 29 late in the fourth to force the extra period, Henry Boyer caught a touchdown to stay alive, and Kenny Minchey found Willie Rodriguez in the end zone for the two point conversion that ended it 35 to 34. First overtime road win in program history and the biggest road comeback the school has ever assembled.
The two and a half never entered into it. Kentucky won outright. Cashed, by the most uncomfortable route available.
-
10 BYU at TCU
BYU -6.5 Cashed BYU 17, TCU 10
BYU is off a bye. TCU is 97th in adjusted EPA per play on offense with a run game at 39.4 percent success and a drive success rate of .323, 106th, which is the profile of a team that stalls rather than one that loses shootouts. BYU lost right tackle Andrew Gentry to surgery and replaces him with freshmen, but BYU has faced the lowest havoc rate in this group at 5.5 percent. TCU gets a revenge angle off last November.
Bachmeier runs it in with 2:06 left and buys the half point
BYU lost LJ Martin to injury and still took Fort Worth. Bear Bachmeier scored twice on the ground, the second from 21 yards with 2:06 on the clock, and that run turned a six point win into a seven point win. Final 17 to 10.
Six and a half was the number and the margin was seven. One play, late, decided by half a point. Cashed, though the other side of that run does not bear thinking about.
-
12 Texas Tech at Colorado
Texas Tech -14.5 Cashed Texas Tech 29, Colorado 7
Colorado owns the worst offense in this group at 121st in adjusted EPA, a 41.0 percent success rate, and a drive success rate of .206 that ranks 129th. Deion Sanders benched Julian Lewis at halftime in Waco and has not named a Week 5 starter, so Texas Tech is preparing for two quarterbacks. SP+ says 23.5 before altitude and home field are charged against it, well past the posted number. Tech has a bye next week.
Four interceptions in Boulder and Texas Tech never sweats
Colorado threw it to the wrong colored jersey four times. John Curry took one back out of the end zone for the free touchdown, Texas Tech moved to 5 and 0, and the Buffaloes managed seven points across the whole afternoon. Final 29 to 7.
Fourteen and a half on the road is a serious number and it stopped being one around the time Curry crossed the goal line. Cashed, with the fourth quarter to spare.
-
4 Miami at Clemson
Miami -16.5 Cashed Miami 41, Clemson 13
Clemson scores 21.0 a game, 120th, behind a true freshman quarterback at 32.3 QBR, and just lost its lead back for the season. Miami leads the country in total offense and is fourth in scoring defense at 9.0, which is the combination that covers whatever the rain does to the passing game. SP+ makes it 20.8 before home field. Miami has a bye the following week, so there is no lookahead to fade.
Miami takes Clemson apart and the number goes with it
Darian Mensah threw for 227 and added a 34 yard touchdown run, Mark Fletcher Jr. got two more on the ground, and Miami left Clemson 41 to 13 with sole possession of first place in the ACC at 5 and 0. Clemson never made it a game worth watching.
Sixteen and a half on the road against a program with that name on the helmet is the kind of number you check twice before you take it. It was right the first time. Cashed.
-
Washington at 18 USC
USC -9.5 Mea culpa Washington 21, USC 25
Washington has not left Seattle this season and now takes a 4:30 local kick in 95 degree heat. Its offense is 98th in adjusted EPA, while Jayden Maiava leads the country in passing yards at 1,499 against two interceptions. USC's defense is the hole at 129th, which is why this is 9.5 and not more, but Washington has to score to exploit it and has not shown that gear. SP+ lands near 8.5.
USC wins on a fumble return and still loses by five and a half
Washington led by double digits in the second half and USC needed a defensive touchdown to dig out. Jahkeem Stewart scooped a fumble and took it 48 yards for the go ahead score, and that play is the entire difference in a 25 to 21 win.
Laying nine and a half said USC would control this game. USC trailed most of it and got saved by a lineman running sideline to sideline. The pick was a bet on an offense that did not show up, which is the worst way to be wrong, because it looks fine in the standings and awful on the ticket.
-
Utah State at 22 Boise St
Boise St -19.5 Mea culpa Utah State 18, Boise St 37
Utah State has turned it over 11 times, tied for the most in the country, and owns the worst success rate in this group at 37.3 percent with a drive success rate of .194, 131st. Boise has won ten straight in the series and Utah State is 2-13 all time in Boise. SP+ lands on 19.4 with the home field, right at the number, and giveaways are how a favorite clears a number that tight.
Boise State wins by 19 and the number was 19 and a half
Maddux Madsen went 17 of 21 for 244 and two touchdowns, Dylan Riley ran in two more, and Boise State handled Utah State 37 to 18 in the first Pac-12 game either program has ever played. A clean, professional, entirely adequate win.
The number was nineteen and a half. The margin was nineteen. Utah State's late points were worth more than anything else that happened on that field, and laying almost three touchdowns puts you at the mercy of exactly that kind of meaningless scoring. No argument with the result. Just the hook.
-
6 Indiana at Rutgers
Indiana -24.5 Cashed Indiana 47, Rutgers 15
SP+ separates these two by 28.5, the widest gap on the board, against a posted 24.5. Rutgers is 112th in SP+ defense and has thrown nine interceptions, 137th, while Indiana has thrown none all season, first in the country. Indiana is 0-3 against the spread and Cignetti called out a 22 minute slow start against Northwestern, which is the case for Rutgers. A defense allowing 9.8 points a game is the case against it.
Indiana makes it 21 straight and covers without breaking stride
Turbo Richard ran for 204, Josh Hoover went 20 of 27 for 251 and four touchdowns, and Indiana turned Piscataway into another line item on a 21 game winning streak. Final 47 to 15.
Twenty four and a half on the road against a Big Ten team is supposed to be a trap number. It has not been a trap with this Indiana team all season, and it was not one here. Cashed, and the back door never got so much as a knock.
How picks are graded
Each pick is made against the spread available when the card is published Wednesday evening, and it locks at kickoff. After the game, the picked team's final margin plus the line decides it: above zero cashes, below zero is a mea culpa, exactly zero is a push. Scores come from ESPN's college scoreboard. Rankings are the AP Top 25 at publication.
Other weeks: Week 12 · Week 11 · Week 10 · Week 9 · Week 8 · Week 7 · Week 6 · Week 4 · Week 3